ADDITIONAL MENU
Post-Publication Discussion Policy
Post-Publication Discussion Policy
Supporting constructive scholarly criticism, author responses, and responsible evaluation of published research.
OPEN SCHOLARLY DIALOGUE FAIR REVIEW ACADEMIC INTEGRITY
Policy Statement
Lughatu Ad-Dhat: Journal of Arabic Languange Education, published by Institut Agama Islam Hamzanwadi Pancor, recognizes that scholarly evaluation continues after publication.
The journal welcomes constructive, evidence-based discussion concerning published articles in Arabic education and Arabic studies. Post-publication contributions are considered in accordance with editorial independence, publication ethics, and relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Core Principle: Publication does not end scholarly scrutiny. Substantive criticism, reasonable disagreement, and author responses are part of academic dialogue. Editorial decisions concerning the publication of responses or corrections must be based on evidence, relevance, fairness, and scholarly merit.
Readers, researchers, authors, and relevant institutions may submit scholarly comments addressing articles already published in Lughatu Ad-Dhat: Journal of Arabic Languange Education.
Appropriate subjects include:
Comments should contribute meaningful scholarly analysis rather than merely express agreement, disagreement, or political preference without supporting arguments.
Post-publication comments, critical responses, or requests for scholarly clarification should be submitted in writing to the Lughatu Ad-Dhat: Journal of Arabic Languange Education Editorial Office.
Submissions should include:
Editorial Submission Channel
Email: [email protected]
Suggested Subject: Post-Publication Discussion – Article DOI / Title
The Editorial Team assesses comments for scholarly relevance, clarity, supporting evidence, originality, professional language, and compliance with publication ethics.
Where appropriate, the editor may request clarification, revision, or independent expert assessment before deciding whether the contribution should be published, communicated to the authors, or handled through another editorial procedure.
The journal does not accept personal attacks, discriminatory statements, unsupported allegations, defamatory material, confidential information disclosed without authorization, or content intended primarily for political or commercial promotion.
Acceptance of a post-publication comment is an editorial decision. Submission does not guarantee publication or the availability of an unrestricted public commenting facility.
When substantive criticism concerns a published article, the Editorial Team may invite the original authors to provide a reasoned response, clarification, or relevant supporting evidence.
Authors are expected to respond professionally, address the specific scholarly issues raised, and acknowledge genuine errors when identified.
Where appropriate, the journal may publish a scholarly comment and the authors' response as related contributions, subject to editorial assessment. All parties must disclose relevant competing interests and respect legitimate differences in scholarly interpretation.
Post-publication discussion may identify errors or integrity concerns requiring action beyond scholarly correspondence.
CorrectionFor significant errors that do not invalidate the principal findings.
Expression of ConcernFor serious unresolved concerns affecting confidence in an article.
RetractionFor materially unreliable findings or serious substantiated violations.
Suspected plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, or other research misconduct is evaluated through the journal's research-integrity and complaints procedures. Legitimate scholarly disagreement alone is not grounds for retraction.
Formal amendments are governed by Arabiyat's Retraction, Withdrawal and Correction (R-W-C) Policy. Where a public notice is required, it should be transparent and linked to the affected publication.
Post-publication discussion must remain respectful, evidence-based, and free from inappropriate political, institutional, financial, or personal influence.
The Editorial Team may decline contributions that are repetitive, irrelevant, inadequately supported, abusive, or inconsistent with scholarly ethics. Confidential research records and personal information must not be publicly disclosed without appropriate authorization.
When scholarly comments and author responses are formally published, the journal should identify their relationship to the original article and preserve appropriate citation and publication records.
Commitment to Scholarly Dialogue
Arabiyat supports responsible post-publication discussion as a means of strengthening critical inquiry, academic accountability, and the reliability of research on Arabic education and Arabic studies.
DiscussionEvidence-Based
Author ResponseEncouraged
Editorial ReviewIndependent
Publication RecordProtected



IAI Hamzanwadi NW Pancor
Lombok Nusa Tenggara Barat
Jl. TGKH M. Zainuddin Abdul Majid No. 134 Pancor, Kec. Selong Lombok Timur Nusa Tenggara Barat
telp / fax: 0376-22566, Email: [email protected],
Koordinat Peta: Lat. -8.6460584, Panjang. 116.5257202
dilisensikan di bawah lisensi Creative Commons Atribusi-NonKomersial 4.0 Internasional .